I spent six months this year studying Finland's education system as a participant in the Fulbright Distinguished Awards in Teaching program. Please contact me at kateyocum@gmail.com.
Saturday, March 12, 2011
Fulbrighters in Finland share their work
Fulbrighters from across Finland convened in Tampere this week to share their research. The topics were virtually without limit - construction site safety, classical Finnish composers, Finnish wood architecture, sustainable foundries, Kalevala environmental performance art, sleep research, social technology, and more. The three of us in the teachers program, Sarah, Binh, and I, also presented. Sarah studies school libraries in Finland, or the lack thereof. Finns have close ties to libraries, however, and public libraries in Finland are superb and accessed by Finns of all ages. Binh studies curriculum, standards, and critical thinking pedagogy. He's a huge fan of the Finnish national core curriculum. I shared what I have learned so far about the achievement of immigrants in Finland and what I have found regarding policies and the actual experiences of students and teachers.
Nicholas Kristof weighs in
Pay Teachers More
Nicholas Kristof
NY Times March 12, 2011
From the debates in Wisconsin and elsewhere about public sector unions, you might get the impression that we’re going bust because teachers are overpaid. That’s a pernicious fallacy. A basic educational challenge is not that teachers are raking it in, but that they are underpaid. If we want to compete with other countries, and chip away at poverty across America, then we need to pay teachers more so as to attract better people into the profession.
Until a few decades ago, employment discrimination perversely strengthened our teaching force. Brilliant women became elementary school teachers, because better jobs weren’t open to them. It was profoundly unfair, but the discrimination did benefit America’s children.
These days, brilliant women become surgeons and investment bankers — and 47 percent of America’s kindergarten through 12th-grade teachers come from the bottom one-third of their college classes (as measured by SAT scores). The figure is from a study by McKinsey & Company, “Closing the Talent Gap.”
Changes in relative pay have reinforced the problem. In 1970, in New York City, a newly minted teacher at a public school earned about $2,000 less in salary than a starting lawyer at a prominent law firm. These days the lawyer takes home, including bonus, $115,000 more than the teacher, the McKinsey study found.
We all understand intuitively the difference a great teacher makes. I think of Juanita Trantina, who left my fifth-grade class intoxicated with excitement for learning and fascinated by the current events she spoke about. You probably have a Miss Trantina in your own past.
One Los Angeles study found that having a teacher from the 25 percent most effective group of teachers for four years in a row would be enough to eliminate the black-white achievement gap.
Recent scholarship suggests that good teachers, even kindergarten teachers, increase their students’ earnings many years later. Eric A. Hanushek of Stanford University found that an excellent teacher (one a standard deviation better than average, or better than 84 percent of teachers) raises each student’s lifetime earnings by $20,000. If there are 20 students in the class, that is an extra $400,000 generated, compared with a teacher who is merely average.
A teacher better than 93 percent of other teachers would add $640,000 to lifetime pay of a class of 20, the study found.
Look, I’m not a fan of teachers’ unions. They used their clout to gain job security more than pay, thus making the field safe for low achievers. Teaching work rules are often inflexible, benefits are generous relative to salaries, and it is difficult or impossible to dismiss teachers who are ineffective.
But none of this means that teachers are overpaid. And if governments nibble away at pensions and reduce job security, then they must pay more in wages to stay even.
Moreover, part of compensation is public esteem. When governors mock teachers as lazy, avaricious incompetents, they demean the profession and make it harder to attract the best and brightest. We should be elevating teachers, not throwing darts at them.
Consider three other countries renowned for their educational performance: Singapore, South Korea and Finland. In each country, teachers are drawn from the top third of their cohort, are hugely respected and are paid well (although that’s less true in Finland). In South Korea and Singapore, teachers on average earn more than lawyers and engineers, the McKinsey study found.
“We’re not going to get better teachers unless we pay them more,” notes Amy Wilkins of the Education Trust, an education reform organization. Likewise, Jeanne Allen of the Center for Education Reform says, “We’re the first people to say, throw them $100,000, throw them whatever it takes.”
Both Ms. Wilkins and Ms. Allen add in the next breath that pay should be for performance, with more rigorous evaluation. That makes sense to me.
Starting teacher pay, which now averages $39,000, would have to rise to $65,000 to fill most new teaching positions in high-needs schools with graduates from the top third of their classes, the McKinsey study found. That would be a bargain.
Indeed, it makes sense to cut corners elsewhere to boost teacher salaries. Research suggests that students would benefit from a tradeoff of better teachers but worse teacher-student ratios. Thus there are growing calls for a Japanese model of larger classes, but with outstanding, respected, well-paid teachers.
Teaching is unusual among the professions in that it pays poorly but has strong union protections and lockstep wage increases. It’s a factory model of compensation, and critics are right to fault it. But the bottom line is that we should pay teachers more, not less — and that politicians who falsely lambaste teachers as greedy are simply making it more difficult to attract the kind of above-average teachers our above-average children deserve.
Nicholas Kristof
NY Times March 12, 2011
From the debates in Wisconsin and elsewhere about public sector unions, you might get the impression that we’re going bust because teachers are overpaid. That’s a pernicious fallacy. A basic educational challenge is not that teachers are raking it in, but that they are underpaid. If we want to compete with other countries, and chip away at poverty across America, then we need to pay teachers more so as to attract better people into the profession.
Until a few decades ago, employment discrimination perversely strengthened our teaching force. Brilliant women became elementary school teachers, because better jobs weren’t open to them. It was profoundly unfair, but the discrimination did benefit America’s children.
These days, brilliant women become surgeons and investment bankers — and 47 percent of America’s kindergarten through 12th-grade teachers come from the bottom one-third of their college classes (as measured by SAT scores). The figure is from a study by McKinsey & Company, “Closing the Talent Gap.”
Changes in relative pay have reinforced the problem. In 1970, in New York City, a newly minted teacher at a public school earned about $2,000 less in salary than a starting lawyer at a prominent law firm. These days the lawyer takes home, including bonus, $115,000 more than the teacher, the McKinsey study found.
We all understand intuitively the difference a great teacher makes. I think of Juanita Trantina, who left my fifth-grade class intoxicated with excitement for learning and fascinated by the current events she spoke about. You probably have a Miss Trantina in your own past.
One Los Angeles study found that having a teacher from the 25 percent most effective group of teachers for four years in a row would be enough to eliminate the black-white achievement gap.
Recent scholarship suggests that good teachers, even kindergarten teachers, increase their students’ earnings many years later. Eric A. Hanushek of Stanford University found that an excellent teacher (one a standard deviation better than average, or better than 84 percent of teachers) raises each student’s lifetime earnings by $20,000. If there are 20 students in the class, that is an extra $400,000 generated, compared with a teacher who is merely average.
A teacher better than 93 percent of other teachers would add $640,000 to lifetime pay of a class of 20, the study found.
Look, I’m not a fan of teachers’ unions. They used their clout to gain job security more than pay, thus making the field safe for low achievers. Teaching work rules are often inflexible, benefits are generous relative to salaries, and it is difficult or impossible to dismiss teachers who are ineffective.
But none of this means that teachers are overpaid. And if governments nibble away at pensions and reduce job security, then they must pay more in wages to stay even.
Moreover, part of compensation is public esteem. When governors mock teachers as lazy, avaricious incompetents, they demean the profession and make it harder to attract the best and brightest. We should be elevating teachers, not throwing darts at them.
Consider three other countries renowned for their educational performance: Singapore, South Korea and Finland. In each country, teachers are drawn from the top third of their cohort, are hugely respected and are paid well (although that’s less true in Finland). In South Korea and Singapore, teachers on average earn more than lawyers and engineers, the McKinsey study found.
“We’re not going to get better teachers unless we pay them more,” notes Amy Wilkins of the Education Trust, an education reform organization. Likewise, Jeanne Allen of the Center for Education Reform says, “We’re the first people to say, throw them $100,000, throw them whatever it takes.”
Both Ms. Wilkins and Ms. Allen add in the next breath that pay should be for performance, with more rigorous evaluation. That makes sense to me.
Starting teacher pay, which now averages $39,000, would have to rise to $65,000 to fill most new teaching positions in high-needs schools with graduates from the top third of their classes, the McKinsey study found. That would be a bargain.
Indeed, it makes sense to cut corners elsewhere to boost teacher salaries. Research suggests that students would benefit from a tradeoff of better teachers but worse teacher-student ratios. Thus there are growing calls for a Japanese model of larger classes, but with outstanding, respected, well-paid teachers.
Teaching is unusual among the professions in that it pays poorly but has strong union protections and lockstep wage increases. It’s a factory model of compensation, and critics are right to fault it. But the bottom line is that we should pay teachers more, not less — and that politicians who falsely lambaste teachers as greedy are simply making it more difficult to attract the kind of above-average teachers our above-average children deserve.
Saturday, February 26, 2011
Early Childhood Education
ECE is not a focus of mine, but I wanted to write about it so that teachers who are interested can have a look.
Here in Finland, one of the big differences is that compulsory education starts a age 7. I am not exactly sure why this is, but there are publicly funded education options for children who are younger than 7. This is called day care or pre-school, and I got to visit one of these schools this week.
Here there are two certified teachers and some assistants. First thing in the morning, children eat breakfast. Breakfast is prepared in the school and has a very un-institutional appearance. (I did not taste the food at this school, but have had many school lunches, all of which were quite good.)
Children gather for morning circle and talk about much the same things you might talk about it a kindergarten or first grade class - the weather, the activities for the day, and the calendar.

There is lots of time to play with toys, do art projects, and even try out computer activities. The older children today had a 45 minutes lesson on counting and listening to and distinguishing between similar sounding words. The teacher explained that the children work up to sitting for 45 minutes, and that this will prepare them for first grade.
Besides the time in class, there is lots of time to play outside and get involved in self-directed activities. I noticed the children entering and exiting the different rooms and interacting with each other as they wished.
As you can see, the school is a bright, warm, inviting place.






Here is some of the work from the students' portfolios.
Here in Finland, one of the big differences is that compulsory education starts a age 7. I am not exactly sure why this is, but there are publicly funded education options for children who are younger than 7. This is called day care or pre-school, and I got to visit one of these schools this week.
Here there are two certified teachers and some assistants. First thing in the morning, children eat breakfast. Breakfast is prepared in the school and has a very un-institutional appearance. (I did not taste the food at this school, but have had many school lunches, all of which were quite good.)
Children gather for morning circle and talk about much the same things you might talk about it a kindergarten or first grade class - the weather, the activities for the day, and the calendar.

There is lots of time to play with toys, do art projects, and even try out computer activities. The older children today had a 45 minutes lesson on counting and listening to and distinguishing between similar sounding words. The teacher explained that the children work up to sitting for 45 minutes, and that this will prepare them for first grade.
Besides the time in class, there is lots of time to play outside and get involved in self-directed activities. I noticed the children entering and exiting the different rooms and interacting with each other as they wished.
As you can see, the school is a bright, warm, inviting place.






Here is some of the work from the students' portfolios.
Sunday, February 13, 2011
Time in school - Two 5th grade classes

Here is a rough calculation that shows the similarities and differences between the school I have been visiting (School A) and our school. The graph shows the number of hours/week students spend learning each subject:
And the number of hours/week students are in school and in class (as opposed to breaks/recess/lunch):
Monday, January 24, 2011
Financial resources and student performance
Tonight I feel a little discouraged. I just read through the information on Beaverton School District's website about the dire financial straits we are in as a district and as a state. The numbers tell the story, but beyond the numbers, I feel that the district has the capacity and will to do all they can to make cuts judiciously, with teaching and learning as its highest priority. However, as it is every year, this is a long and drawn out process that puts stress on all 6,000 educators in the district and takes the focus off of teaching and learning. I remember now why I opted to take my professional leave in the spring, to get a break from budget drama and from state testing. Each spring, I feel the frustration of teaching time lost to working out testing schedules, testing multiple times in up to four different subjects, and an overall interruption to the curriculum.
No superintendent or individual at the state department of education has the power to change our budget situation. And, in an increasingly centralized education system, we have little power to redirect our time and attention to teaching and learning from the hours spent in a computer lab completing required state tests.
In Finland, I am trying to figure out how they balance it all. Look at exhibit 1, a table of per pupil expenditures in relation to scores on the PISA. (The PISA is the "Programme for International Student Assessment," the core measurement tool used to compare student performance across industrialized countries. It is developed by the OECD for the purposes of member countries.)

It case you can't read it, the U.S. spends 43% more on each pupil than Finland does. But Finnish students scored an average of 61 points higher than American students did on the PISA math assessment.
How can I reconcile this lower price tag with what I have seen in schools so far? These are beautiful buildings, with ample classroom space, labs, workshops; a wide-array of curricular options, low(er) teacher/student ratios, and well-paid, well-respected teachers. The atmosphere in a Finnish school is not one of rushing about getting from one place to the next, constant assessment, and exhausting schedules. Teachers work hard, but they and their students are much more relaxed.
And teacher/student contact hours are half of what they are in the U.S.? How can this be?
I have my work cut out for me.
No superintendent or individual at the state department of education has the power to change our budget situation. And, in an increasingly centralized education system, we have little power to redirect our time and attention to teaching and learning from the hours spent in a computer lab completing required state tests.
In Finland, I am trying to figure out how they balance it all. Look at exhibit 1, a table of per pupil expenditures in relation to scores on the PISA. (The PISA is the "Programme for International Student Assessment," the core measurement tool used to compare student performance across industrialized countries. It is developed by the OECD for the purposes of member countries.)

It case you can't read it, the U.S. spends 43% more on each pupil than Finland does. But Finnish students scored an average of 61 points higher than American students did on the PISA math assessment.
How can I reconcile this lower price tag with what I have seen in schools so far? These are beautiful buildings, with ample classroom space, labs, workshops; a wide-array of curricular options, low(er) teacher/student ratios, and well-paid, well-respected teachers. The atmosphere in a Finnish school is not one of rushing about getting from one place to the next, constant assessment, and exhausting schedules. Teachers work hard, but they and their students are much more relaxed.
And teacher/student contact hours are half of what they are in the U.S.? How can this be?
I have my work cut out for me.
Saturday, January 22, 2011
My Fulbright colleague from Olympia
Here's an article from the Olympian talking about my colleague Sarah Applegate who will be arriving in a few weeks.
Friday, January 21, 2011
Google Alerts
This article was emailed to me because I have signed up for a Google alert for the keywords "education" and "Finland." Reading the first paragraph made me laugh.
I haven't yet studied carefully the Common Core Standards, but I did get my hands on the Finnish national curriculum this week, and will make some comparisons of my own. Perhaps that will be the secret to finding the 'educational promised land (also known as “Finland”).'
I haven't yet studied carefully the Common Core Standards, but I did get my hands on the Finnish national curriculum this week, and will make some comparisons of my own. Perhaps that will be the secret to finding the 'educational promised land (also known as “Finland”).'
Thursday, January 20, 2011
Languages related to Finnish
Yes, it is true, Finnish is not related to any other European languages except Hungarian and Estonian. Finnish has something called the "partitive" case, which I just learned today in class. Actually, I should say that I was introduced to it today in class.
Here is a helpful map indicating which languages are in the same family as Finnish:

Today I learned how to say "There are four mice." - Kuvassa on neljä hiirtä. That's enough about Finnish for today.
Here is a helpful map indicating which languages are in the same family as Finnish:

Today I learned how to say "There are four mice." - Kuvassa on neljä hiirtä. That's enough about Finnish for today.
Wednesday, January 12, 2011
Hello William Walker ES -Greetings from Finland!
Hello William Walker Elementary School! I am writing to you from Tampere, Finland. Tampere is Finland's third largest city. Right now it is covered in snow. Here is a picture that I took on a walk last weekend. Everything is white (or grey).

In Tampere today, the sun will rise at 9:29 am and sets at 3:38 pm. So, how many hours of daylight will I have today? It's 7:30am now, still hours away from sunrise.
Even during the day, it is quite dark here. I haven't yet seen the sun in Finland.
Let me tell you how I got here. On January 4th, I left Portland and flew to New Jersey. An hour later I left New Jersey and flew to Munich, Germany. That flight took almost nine hours. Finally, I flew from Munich, Germany to Helsinki, Finland.

Then I took a train to Tampere, which took an hour and forty-five minutes.
Tampere is the largest inland Scaninavian city. This means that it's is the largest city in the countries of Finland, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and Iceland that is not located on the coast. There are about 215,000 people here. That's about twice the size of Beaverton, I think.
I live in a small apartment in an apartment building in town. I can walk wherever I need to go. But I dress up in warm clothes before I go anywhere. Here are a few pictures from my walk today:



Next time I will show you the university where I am working and the really cool machines they have in town to remove snow. Let me know what else you would like to know about Finland. I will try to find out. I am learning a little each day, but still have quite a lot to learn.

In Tampere today, the sun will rise at 9:29 am and sets at 3:38 pm. So, how many hours of daylight will I have today? It's 7:30am now, still hours away from sunrise.
Even during the day, it is quite dark here. I haven't yet seen the sun in Finland.
Let me tell you how I got here. On January 4th, I left Portland and flew to New Jersey. An hour later I left New Jersey and flew to Munich, Germany. That flight took almost nine hours. Finally, I flew from Munich, Germany to Helsinki, Finland.

Then I took a train to Tampere, which took an hour and forty-five minutes.
Tampere is the largest inland Scaninavian city. This means that it's is the largest city in the countries of Finland, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and Iceland that is not located on the coast. There are about 215,000 people here. That's about twice the size of Beaverton, I think.
I live in a small apartment in an apartment building in town. I can walk wherever I need to go. But I dress up in warm clothes before I go anywhere. Here are a few pictures from my walk today:



Next time I will show you the university where I am working and the really cool machines they have in town to remove snow. Let me know what else you would like to know about Finland. I will try to find out. I am learning a little each day, but still have quite a lot to learn.
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
Diane Ravitch wonders if we should care about PISA...
'...Finland is at the other end of the educational spectrum. Its education system is modeled on American progressive ideas. It is student-centered. It has a broad (and non-directive) national curriculum. Its teachers are drawn from the top 10 percent of university graduates. They are highly educated and well prepared. Students never take a high-stakes test; their teachers make their own tests. The only test they take that counts is the one required to enter university.
Last week, I went to a luncheon with Pasi Sahlberg, the Finnish education expert. I asked him the question that every politician asks today: "If students don't take tests, how do you hold teachers and schools accountable?" He said that there is no word in the Finnish language for "accountability." He said, "We put well-prepared teachers in the classroom, give them maximum autonomy, and we trust them to be responsible."
I asked him if teachers are paid more for experience. He said, "Of course." And what about graduate degrees? He said, "Every teacher in Finland has a master's degree." He added: "We don't believe in competition among students, teachers, or schools. We believe in collaboration, trust, responsibility, and autonomy."...'
Read the whole article from Education Week here.
Last week, I went to a luncheon with Pasi Sahlberg, the Finnish education expert. I asked him the question that every politician asks today: "If students don't take tests, how do you hold teachers and schools accountable?" He said that there is no word in the Finnish language for "accountability." He said, "We put well-prepared teachers in the classroom, give them maximum autonomy, and we trust them to be responsible."
I asked him if teachers are paid more for experience. He said, "Of course." And what about graduate degrees? He said, "Every teacher in Finland has a master's degree." He added: "We don't believe in competition among students, teachers, or schools. We believe in collaboration, trust, responsibility, and autonomy."...'
Read the whole article from Education Week here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
